5 thoughts on “Why wasn't Jin Yong's martial arts novel "White Horse Xiao Wind" being filmed into a movie or TV series?”
Candace
"White Horse Xiaofeng" is mainly manifested in people's inner feelings, so in this whole story, there are very few drama parts suitable for showing martial arts or fighting plots. The character image inside lacks sufficient characteristics. If it is difficult for the audience to pay for it, compared to today's industry trends, it will not take this danger at all.
All the works of Jin Yong have been filmed as movies or TV series, including "White Horse Guanxi Wind", but it is too unpopular. Many people may read the trilogy of shooting carving, Tianlong, Xiao Ao, etc., but may not have watched it before "White Horse Xiao West Wind". It is also a chance to read "White Horse Xiaofeng". I like to read martial arts novels in middle school, and there will be no money. I will rent a book on the ground in the summer vacation. I will buy it for those who like it very much. At that time, Jin Yong's books were often converted into a pirated version of one. West Wind "and" Sword "and" Yue Girl Sword ". It the characteristics of Jin Yong's novels. Most of his well -known head works are the big male lead. Even the heaviest Huang Rong in the drama is the little woman around Guo Jing. So many women don't like Jin Yong and feel that he has degraded the female status. However, Jin Yong's three short and medium stories are completely different. Both "Yue Girls' Sword" and "White Horse Xiao Wind" are the core figures of women as books. The master of Jin Yong is absolutely handy in writing the male master's drama, and it is estimated that he is also dominated by men. Therefore, the quality of his short and medium stories is obviously not as good as his long system. The hostess in the book is Li Wenxiu, which is also a martial arts family. Because of the disaster of the parents, the Kazakhs of the Kazakhs grew up with a grandfather with a surname. The younger she had made friends with the Kazakh young man Sup and fell in love with him, but Supu liked the same girl Aman. Later, Li Wenxiu had no intention of encountering a sheltered master Huahui. This Huahui was a very powerful master, but he was vicious and dull, and he was severely poisoned. Li Wenxiu helped him remove the poison needle, so he taught Li Wenxiu's work. Seeing this, this routine is no different from other martial arts novels. It has become a woman. The situation was a bit interesting. It turned out that Huahui was actually a Kazakh, called Valrazi, and Grandpa Ji was pretending to be an old man. The true identity was Huahui apprentice. At that time, Wallazi and Oman dad were rivals, because Omann did not marry him, so she poisoned her, and wanted to poison the entire tribe in the well. His apprentice Grandpa couldn't bear it, so he first sent a poison needle to subdue Valrazi. In the end, Oman Dad, Grandpa Ji, Valrazi fought in one place, Grandpa Ji was killed, and Vallazin's abdomen was also stabbed by Grandpa. Li Wenxiu found that the true identity of the two was very sad, but Na Vallazi was very poisonous. Before dying, Li Wenxiu accompanied him. In the end, Li Wenxiu left because he was too serious and did not succeed. Sup was still with Oman. I. although this novel is the protagonist, the kernel is still a man, such as Li Wenxiu. After the completion of martial arts, it is much higher than Sup, but he still likes Supu, a simple Kazakh boy. The main grievances in the book are the grievances between Grandpa Li Wenxiu and Walrazi who taught her martial arts. If you look at the ability alone, Li Wenxiu is stronger than Oman, Valrazi is stronger than Oman's father, but neither of them get what they want. Does the whole book want to reflect this idea? The entire book clue and scarce characters. If the TV series is adapted, it is necessary to greatly increase the plot. If the movie is adapted, it is estimated that the original plot must be adjusted. This is tantamount to re -editing a story, nothing more than Jin Yong's name. The most important thing is that this work is too popular. For example, the "Swordsman", "Tianlong Babu", "Lu Ding Ji", which was adapted from Jin Yong, became a movie. It is all the way to change, and even the name of the protagonist is different. Why do you have to pull Jin Yong's work, mainly because those works are too famous and have a great influence. The name of "White Horse Xiao West Wind" is obviously not so much influence. . No matter how powerful a writer is, it is difficult to achieve every work. Now, if you shoot "White Horse Flower West Wind", you may be able to shoot well, but it is likely that the story is very different from the original story. In this case, why should you be obsessed with the name and work of the play.
"White Horse Xiaofeng" is the most special one among the fifteen novels of Mr. Jin Yong. What needs to be corrected is that at the beginning, Mr. Jin Yong wrote to be a movie script, but was later filmed as a TV series. However, because of its flat plot and lyricism, there is a lack of fighting scenes, so it is not a very attractive novel, and no investors are willing to remake. The Mr. Jin Yong started writing, but in just 12 years, he created a full 15 popular works in these 12 years. Once the first serialized novel "Sword Sword and Enemies" came out, it caused a huge response, and countless people were waiting to be updated every day. If there was such a statement that was more urged at that time, it is estimated that Mr. Jin Yong was urged by us. "White Horse Xiao West Wind" is less than 80,000 words written by Mr. Jin Yong at the end of 1961, and it has been written in two months. As the seventh novel of Mr. Jin Yong, this is the six books, which are completely different from the previous eight books. And Mr. Jin Yong's only novel with women as the main character. It sounds like "White Horse Xiaofeng" should be a very classic novel, but why is no one remake it? The first point: the narrative method is too special. The strokes of the whole novel "White Horse Xiaofeng" are very delicate. Most of the books are described by psychological activities. If you read the novel The requirements of the actors are too harsh. I don't know how to shoot to take the rich inner activities of the characters in the book. The second point: the plot is not attractive enough. Because this is a story with a woman as the protagonist, the whole novel is more about love, not fighting. As a male writer, Mr. Jin Yong is obviously not as good as Aunt Qiong Yao in emotional description. If you want to watch love novels or TV series, then look at Aunt Qiong Yao. Why not look at this not so wonderful "White Horse"? Third point: lack of fighting difficulty to create conflicts. Other works of Mr. Jin Yong either have heroes, either a peerless method, or to set off a storm in martial arts, or worship. Several men chase a woman, and a few women chase a man ... Anyway, there are all kinds of booes, and Most of the fighting scenes are very attractive. However, the plot in "White Horse Gold West Wind" is too ordinary, and lacks some bright scenes of fighting. This makes this novel very embarrassing. If you write it, it ’s not good. In fact, it’ s good. If you write well, you almost feel it. Mas do you let people shoot such a work? It is not exciting enough to make a movie, and it is not enough to make a TV drama plot. Anyway, it still tastes like it is not attractive enough. In fact, although "White Horse" West Wind is not made into a movie, it is still filmed as a TV series. But just like the problems we mentioned above, once the TV series "White Horse Xiao Wind" was broadcast, the response was mediocre, and even many people didn't know that there was this drama, and there was no impression on this. This is probably the most common one among the many works of Mr. Jin Yong. After all, no matter how powerful the writer, there are always one or two works that have been used.
Because this is a novel in the middle chapter, if you want to change into a TV series, the content is too small, and there is any content filled in it, so it is not made into a movie or TV series.
Because this novel is the first work of Mr. Jin Yong, the structure of writing and the plot is still inadequate, and the content is relatively simple, it is not suitable for film and television.
"White Horse Xiaofeng" is mainly manifested in people's inner feelings, so in this whole story, there are very few drama parts suitable for showing martial arts or fighting plots. The character image inside lacks sufficient characteristics. If it is difficult for the audience to pay for it, compared to today's industry trends, it will not take this danger at all.
All the works of Jin Yong have been filmed as movies or TV series, including "White Horse Guanxi Wind", but it is too unpopular. Many people may read the trilogy of shooting carving, Tianlong, Xiao Ao, etc., but may not have watched it before "White Horse Xiao West Wind".
It is also a chance to read "White Horse Xiaofeng". I like to read martial arts novels in middle school, and there will be no money. I will rent a book on the ground in the summer vacation. I will buy it for those who like it very much. At that time, Jin Yong's books were often converted into a pirated version of one. West Wind "and" Sword "and" Yue Girl Sword ".
It the characteristics of Jin Yong's novels. Most of his well -known head works are the big male lead. Even the heaviest Huang Rong in the drama is the little woman around Guo Jing. So many women don't like Jin Yong and feel that he has degraded the female status. However, Jin Yong's three short and medium stories are completely different. Both "Yue Girls' Sword" and "White Horse Xiao Wind" are the core figures of women as books.
The master of Jin Yong is absolutely handy in writing the male master's drama, and it is estimated that he is also dominated by men. Therefore, the quality of his short and medium stories is obviously not as good as his long system.
The hostess in the book is Li Wenxiu, which is also a martial arts family. Because of the disaster of the parents, the Kazakhs of the Kazakhs grew up with a grandfather with a surname. The younger she had made friends with the Kazakh young man Sup and fell in love with him, but Supu liked the same girl Aman. Later, Li Wenxiu had no intention of encountering a sheltered master Huahui. This Huahui was a very powerful master, but he was vicious and dull, and he was severely poisoned. Li Wenxiu helped him remove the poison needle, so he taught Li Wenxiu's work. Seeing this, this routine is no different from other martial arts novels. It has become a woman.
The situation was a bit interesting. It turned out that Huahui was actually a Kazakh, called Valrazi, and Grandpa Ji was pretending to be an old man. The true identity was Huahui apprentice. At that time, Wallazi and Oman dad were rivals, because Omann did not marry him, so she poisoned her, and wanted to poison the entire tribe in the well. His apprentice Grandpa couldn't bear it, so he first sent a poison needle to subdue Valrazi. In the end, Oman Dad, Grandpa Ji, Valrazi fought in one place, Grandpa Ji was killed, and Vallazin's abdomen was also stabbed by Grandpa. Li Wenxiu found that the true identity of the two was very sad, but Na Vallazi was very poisonous. Before dying, Li Wenxiu accompanied him. In the end, Li Wenxiu left because he was too serious and did not succeed. Sup was still with Oman.
I. although this novel is the protagonist, the kernel is still a man, such as Li Wenxiu. After the completion of martial arts, it is much higher than Sup, but he still likes Supu, a simple Kazakh boy. The main grievances in the book are the grievances between Grandpa Li Wenxiu and Walrazi who taught her martial arts. If you look at the ability alone, Li Wenxiu is stronger than Oman, Valrazi is stronger than Oman's father, but neither of them get what they want. Does the whole book want to reflect this idea?
The entire book clue and scarce characters. If the TV series is adapted, it is necessary to greatly increase the plot. If the movie is adapted, it is estimated that the original plot must be adjusted. This is tantamount to re -editing a story, nothing more than Jin Yong's name.
The most important thing is that this work is too popular. For example, the "Swordsman", "Tianlong Babu", "Lu Ding Ji", which was adapted from Jin Yong, became a movie. It is all the way to change, and even the name of the protagonist is different. Why do you have to pull Jin Yong's work, mainly because those works are too famous and have a great influence. The name of "White Horse Xiao West Wind" is obviously not so much influence.
. No matter how powerful a writer is, it is difficult to achieve every work. Now, if you shoot "White Horse Flower West Wind", you may be able to shoot well, but it is likely that the story is very different from the original story. In this case, why should you be obsessed with the name and work of the play.
"White Horse Xiaofeng" is the most special one among the fifteen novels of Mr. Jin Yong. What needs to be corrected is that at the beginning, Mr. Jin Yong wrote to be a movie script, but was later filmed as a TV series. However, because of its flat plot and lyricism, there is a lack of fighting scenes, so it is not a very attractive novel, and no investors are willing to remake.
The Mr. Jin Yong started writing, but in just 12 years, he created a full 15 popular works in these 12 years. Once the first serialized novel "Sword Sword and Enemies" came out, it caused a huge response, and countless people were waiting to be updated every day. If there was such a statement that was more urged at that time, it is estimated that Mr. Jin Yong was urged by us.
"White Horse Xiao West Wind" is less than 80,000 words written by Mr. Jin Yong at the end of 1961, and it has been written in two months. As the seventh novel of Mr. Jin Yong, this is the six books, which are completely different from the previous eight books. And Mr. Jin Yong's only novel with women as the main character. It sounds like "White Horse Xiaofeng" should be a very classic novel, but why is no one remake it?
The first point: the narrative method is too special. The strokes of the whole novel "White Horse Xiaofeng" are very delicate. Most of the books are described by psychological activities. If you read the novel The requirements of the actors are too harsh. I don't know how to shoot to take the rich inner activities of the characters in the book.
The second point: the plot is not attractive enough. Because this is a story with a woman as the protagonist, the whole novel is more about love, not fighting. As a male writer, Mr. Jin Yong is obviously not as good as Aunt Qiong Yao in emotional description. If you want to watch love novels or TV series, then look at Aunt Qiong Yao. Why not look at this not so wonderful "White Horse"?
Third point: lack of fighting difficulty to create conflicts. Other works of Mr. Jin Yong either have heroes, either a peerless method, or to set off a storm in martial arts, or worship. Several men chase a woman, and a few women chase a man ... Anyway, there are all kinds of booes, and Most of the fighting scenes are very attractive. However, the plot in "White Horse Gold West Wind" is too ordinary, and lacks some bright scenes of fighting. This makes this novel very embarrassing. If you write it, it ’s not good. In fact, it’ s good. If you write well, you almost feel it.
Mas do you let people shoot such a work? It is not exciting enough to make a movie, and it is not enough to make a TV drama plot. Anyway, it still tastes like it is not attractive enough.
In fact, although "White Horse" West Wind is not made into a movie, it is still filmed as a TV series. But just like the problems we mentioned above, once the TV series "White Horse Xiao Wind" was broadcast, the response was mediocre, and even many people didn't know that there was this drama, and there was no impression on this. This is probably the most common one among the many works of Mr. Jin Yong. After all, no matter how powerful the writer, there are always one or two works that have been used.
Because this is a novel in the middle chapter, if you want to change into a TV series, the content is too small, and there is any content filled in it, so it is not made into a movie or TV series.
Because this novel is the first work of Mr. Jin Yong, the structure of writing and the plot is still inadequate, and the content is relatively simple, it is not suitable for film and television.